Save 4%
$5.04
$4.85
Save 4%
Dairy
Save 4%
Save 13%
$3.90
$3.38
Whipping Cream, 1 pt
Paint Valley Farms
Farm Fresh Non-Homogenized Pasteurized Grade Certified Organic Non-GMO Ingredients Grade A pasteurized Whipping Cream ...
View full details
$3.90
$3.38
Save 13%
Save 8%
$6.45
$5.95
Goats Milk 1/2gal
Paint Valley Farms
Low temperature, Vat pasteurizes. Grade A, Whole Milk Ingredients Goats Milk
$6.45
$5.95
Save 8%
Save 14%
$4.95
$4.28
Organic Eggs, 1 Dozen
Green Field Farms
Large brown organic eggs. Wholesome values. Wholesome food. Nutrition Facts
$4.95
$4.28
Save 14%
Save 2%
$3.69
$3.62
Organic Half and Half, 16 oz.
Organic Valley
There’s pasture-raised richness you can taste in every drop of Organic Valley Half & Half. Thanks to our organic ingredients, it’s perfect for ...
View full details
$3.69
$3.62
Save 2%
Save 24%
$5.85
$4.46
Cheddar Cheese, 1 lb
Paint Valley Farms
Ingredients Grade A Pasturized Cow's milk, Bacerial Culture, Salt and Rennet
$5.85
$4.46
Save 24%
Sold out
$4.92
Organic Cream Cheese, 8 oz.
Organic Valley
Too often, cream cheese gets overlooked. That’s a shame, because when you use pasture-raised milk like we do, you get cream cheese that’s the perfe...
View full details
$4.92
Sold out
Sale
from $3.74
Mozzarella Cheese
Paint Valley Farms
Ingredients: Pasteurized Part Skim Milk,Salt, Rennet, Cultures
from $3.74
Sale
Save 30%
$6.99
$4.91
Shredded Cheddar Cheese, 16 oz
Paint Valley Farms
Ingredients: Grade A pasteurized cow’s milk, bacterial culture, salt, rennet
$6.99
$4.91
Save 30%
Save 10%
$5.58
$5.02
Butter Sticks, 4 ct
Melt Organic
Melt Organic Butter Sticks bake and cook just like real butter and that means no measurements, no calculations and no revisions. Just replace the o...
View full details
$5.58
$5.02
Save 10%
Save 21%
$5.50
$4.32
Save 21%
$6.14
Rich & Creamy MELT® Organic Butter Spread
melt
Melt Organic is made from the Perfect Blend™ of fruit- and plant-based oils. It’s dairy-free, vegan and features certified organic, non-GMO virgin ...
View full details
$6.14
$9.49
Traditional Flavor yogurt starter Culture
Cultures For Health
This Traditional Yogurt Starter is a pleasantly tangy direct-set yogurt starter that is easy to use. Make yogurt when you need to and freeze the re...
View full details
$9.49
$4.80
$4.10
Chocolate milk,1/2 gal
Paint Valley Farms
Ingredients: Milk, Organic Cane Sugar, Cocoa (Processed with Alkali), Dextrose, Cornstarch, Salt, Carrageenan and Natural Vanilla.
$4.80
$4.10
Save 15%
from $5.67
Colby Cheese
Paint Valley Farms
Ingredients: Grade A Pasteurized Cow’s Milk, Bacterial Culture, Salt and Rennet.
from $5.67
$3.57
Natural Bliss Creamer, Almond milk- Vanilla 16oz
coffee-mate
Coffeemate Natural Bliss Almond Milk Coffee Creamer Vanilla Flavor brings a creamy, delicious vanilla flavor to your morning cup. It’s made with re...
View full details
$3.57
$3.57
Natural Bliss Creamer: Sweet Cream 16oz
coffee-mate
Coffeemate Natural Bliss Sweet Cream flavor coffee creamer adds naturally delicious goodness into every cup you pour. We start with real milk and c...
View full details
$3.57
Save 9%
$5.19
$4.70
Organic Sour Cream, 16 oz
Organic Valley
Tangy, creamy, and filled with pasture-raised, probiotic goodness, Organic Valley Sour Cream is the perfect addition to baked potatoes, spreadable...
View full details
$5.19
$4.70
Save 9%
$10.58
Salted Roll Butter, 2 lb
Minerva Dairy
Our 2 lb.(approx.) Amish-style Roll Butter is 84% butterfat and made by the batch in a churn. Keep Refrigerated Nutrition Facts
$10.58
$7.51
Organic Cheese - Pepper Jack, 8 oz. block
Organic Valley
Our Pepper Jack can add some spicy, organic goodness to sandwiches, appetizers and nachos. We use organic peppers and pasture-raised milk, which he...
View full details
$7.51
$7.54
Organic Cottage Cheese - 2% Milkfat - Small Curd, 16 oz.
Organic Valley
More protein, less fat—Organic Valley Lowfat Cottage Cheese packs 15 grams of protein and a mere two grams of fat into each serving. It’s a nutriti...
View full details
$7.54
$3.57
Natural Bliss Creamer: Vanilla, 16 oz
coffee-mate
Coffeemate Natural Bliss Vanilla flavor coffee creamer adds naturally delicious goodness into every cup you pour. We start with real milk and cream...
View full details
$3.57
Save 11%
$5.80
$5.14
Goat Cheese-Garlic Herb, 6 oz
Paint Valley Farms
Ingredients: Grade A Raw Goat Milk, Bacterial Culture, Salt, Rennet, Garlic and Parsley.
$5.80
$5.14
Save 11%
$11.57
Organic Butter - Unsalted, 16 oz.
Organic Valley
Our Cultured Unsalted Butter is meticulously churned by our master buttermakers for results you can taste. It takes time to create the creamy, comp...
View full details
$11.57